From the writing to the story line, this YA tale was a little too bubble gum sweet for me. I didn't feel like Peter did enough to help Libby. Hello! You don't have to change your number when your phone breaks! I also didn't like the fact that Libby seemed to become slightly obsessed with Peter only after finding out who he was. I didn't get enough insight into their developing relationship to believe in their love. I would've appreciated some closure with her dad & her life in Rockville.